Orders ship Monday – Thursday to avoid weekend delays. Standard orders ship in 1–3 business days; custom/branded cookies ship in 3–5 business days. For more details see our Shipping Info page.
Thanksgiving Pies (Local Pickup Only)
Thanksgiving Pies (Local Pickup Only)
From $10.00
Regular price
$10.00
Regular price
Sale price
$10.00
Couldn't load pickup availability
Free delivery for purchases over $60*
Discounts available on bulk orders
Flexible & secure payment
Product Description
Make Thanksgiving a little sweeter with freshly baked pies from Spectrum of Sweets! Each pie features a handmade, flaky crust and is prepared with care by our team of autistic bakers.
Choose from three delicious flavors:
-
Apple Crumb – Sweet apple filling topped with a buttery, golden crumb topping.
-
Cherry – Sweet and tart cherry filling with a flaky lattice crust.
-
Pumpkin – Classic, creamy pumpkin pie with warm fall spices.
Available Sizes & Pricing
-
Individual Mini Pies: $10 each
-
Mini Pie Trio: $25 (includes one of each flavor)
-
9-Inch Pies: $18 each
PRE-ORDERS ONLY until Thursday, Nov 17th – LOCAL PICKUP ONLY
Note your preferred pickup date at checkout:
-
Tuesday, November 24, 2026
-
Wednesday, November 25, 2026
Pickup Hours: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Pickup Location: Pickerington Senior Center, Pickerington, Ohio
These pies are available for local pickup only and cannot be shipped.
Every purchase supports meaningful employment opportunities for autistic adults. Thank you for supporting Spectrum of Sweets this Thanksgiving!
Shipping & Delivery Times
All-Purpose
Flour
Brown Sugar
& Cane Sugar
Unsalted
Butter
Farm-Fresh
Eggs
Natural Vanilla
Extract
Baked with Love for Your Sweetest Celebrations
Our baby shower cookies aren’t just treats — they’re handmade moments of joy. Crafted in small batches with premium ingredients, these cookies are designed to bring smiles, start conversations, and complete your celebration with a sweet touch. themed aesthetics that make them an instant hit at any gathering.
Each cookie is baked fresh in small batches using premium ingredients like creamy butter, farm-fresh eggs, and rich Belgian chocolate or vanilla accents.
Made fresh to order
Custom colors and messages available
Available in themed shapes: baby feet, onesies, bottles, hearts
How We Make Them
Each baby shower cookie begins with a promise: to create something as memorable and heartfelt as your celebration. We follow a mindful, handcrafted approach that brings together traditional baking techniques with baby-themed creativity.
Crafted to Order
Once we receive your order, our team prepares everything from scratch – no pre-made mixes.
Measured & Mixed with Care
Every ingredient is hand-measured and mixed to ensure the perfect consistency and flavor.
Custom-Colored Icing
Our decorators add pastel icing with hand-piped messages or names – based on your selection.
Lovingly Packed
Once cooled, cookies are safely packed in themed boxes.
